Wednesday, November 10, 2004 Outsourcing continues its series of debates between John Irons and Tyler Cowen. This time: outsourcing. It distresses me to report that I find Cowen more convincing than Irons. This because Irons has the CV I would like to have (Swarthmore, MIT, academia, think tanks) and the ideological cast of mind I think that I have: a liberal neo-liberal.

Cowen argues that if you include all the cross-border movement of jobs, that America is doing far less bad than you might think. He cites an OFII article which argues that while 10 million "American" jobs have gone abroad, 6.5 million "foreign" jobs have come to America. He argues that if there is a problem with outsourcing, the solution is simply trying to improve the "business environment" in the U.S. Here I disagree with him, I'm very skeptical of the claim that school choice will improve education (it seems to be about neutral) and that the tax and regulatory burden holds back American business, but the point that outsourcing isn't that important I agree with.

Irons has a rhetorical problem. He wants to say that we should be concerned with outsourcing, but he doesn't cite any evidence to support his case. He is reduced to an argument from morality that we should care about American workers -- and thus have a social safety net. I agree, but he doesn't really get anywhere near laying out a cogent case. One would do far better to read Dani Rodrik than muddle through Irons. Such a case isn't that hard to make: x number of workers have lost their jobs through outsourcing, we value them as citizens, so we should have a social safety net.

Cowen closes with a rant against public sector training, arguing that it is inefficient. Perhaps some programs are, but I see no logical reason why private sector training is any better than public sector training. This is a point to which I'll probably return, but the public-choice argument that governments are by definition inefficient and rent-seeking strikes me as deeply problematic both empirically and theoretically. So Cowen's public policy -- leave it to the market! -- is stupid. Yet, alas, I wish Irons could latch onto the problems with Cowen's argument rather than just circling.


Anonymous :Interactive Web Visions --- Cost Effective Web Support Services. said...

Interactive Web Visions --- Cost Effective Web Support Services.

We offer cost effective web support services. We try our best to strengthen your customer interaction using variety of tools. We specialize in supporting your company at back end in efficient way. Many companies are outsourcing their support work to us, Try us once and see the difference...


Check our Website:

4:59 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Iwebresources: Looking for some IT projects.

Interactive Web Resources is an outsourcing company focused on serving the needs of Small Medium & Large size Businesses in the U.K, Australia, U.S, Europe, Canada & English speaking countries.

Interactive Web Resources as your outsourcing partner help's you to increase your profits, reduce business risk and create breakout value with new services and revenue streams.

IT Out sourcing Is Our Business
We are a Delhi based IT out sourcing company. Providing quality IT related services have been our focus ever since May 2004. From web site designing to web support, we deliver cost effective and reliable systems.There is no doubt that IT out sourcing is a most effective way to stretch your budget.

Whether you need any type of IT related services we have what you need at prices you can afford At Interactive Web Resources, our goal is to provide you with courteous, expedient, professional service of the highest caliber. Browse our Web site for more information about Interactive Web Resources. At Interactive Web Resources, the customer always comes first. We serve you Better.

Our Focus
Our focus is to serve the most professionally managed Overseas companies / Leading IT Companies / MNC's and Any type of company, who demands IT related services of highest standard & wants to avail the same with a difference.

We provide professional services in: -
* Data Entry & Copy Writing
* Web Designing & Web Promotions
* Content Writing
* Graphic Designing
* E-Commerce Solutions
* Web Support
* 24/7 Live Support
* You Name A Service & We Render It.


3:39 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home